How much does being the incumbent help?
The short answer
- Being the incumbent, the person who already holds the office, still helps, but in U.S. House races its estimated value fell to 1.2 percentage points of the vote in 2024, the lowest since the 1950s. (Jacobson, 2025)
- The House edge shrank along with rising party loyalty, straight-ticket voting and House races tied to the presidential race, all of which one study traces to deepening divisions between the parties' voters. (Jacobson, 2015)
- In U.S. history through 2012, a party whose president ran again kept the White House 22 of 32 times, more often than when no incumbent ran. (Mayhew, 2013)
What the studies found
- In U.S. House elections, one estimate of how many votes being the incumbent is worth fell from 8.6 percentage points in 2000 to 1.2 in 2024. (Jacobson, 2025)
- In 2024, two large national surveys each found that 95 percent of voters chose the same party for president and for U.S. House, matching or beating the highest levels ever recorded. (Jacobson, 2025)
- A study of U.S. House elections finds the incumbent's edge fell to levels not seen since the 1950s, as party loyalty, straight-ticket voting and president-centered elections rose. (Jacobson, 2015)
- Across U.S. statewide offices, from governor and senator to state auditor, one study finds the incumbent's edge rose from about 2 percentage points of the vote in the 1940s to about 10 in the 1980s and 1990s. (Ansolabehere and Snyder, 2012)
- In the two decades before 2012, the same authors find, the incumbent's edge in U.S. House races dropped sharply compared with the edge in top statewide offices such as governor and senator. (Ansolabehere and Snyder, 2012)
- A study of U.S. Senate and governor elections finds that presidential and national politics now shape both, though governor races vary more from region to region. (Sievert and McKee, 2019)
- Counting 55 U.S. presidential elections from 1792 to 2012, a party whose president ran again kept the White House 69 percent of the time, compared with 48 percent when no incumbent ran. (Mayhew, 2013)
- In 9,131 U.S. mayoral elections from 1950 to 2014, a candidate who barely won was about 37 percentage points more likely to run and win the next election than one who barely lost. (de Benedictis-Kessner, 2018)
- In city council races in Austin, Dallas, San Antonio and San Jose from 1915 to 1985, serving a term raised a member's vote share by about 10 percentage points when they ran again. (Trounstine, 2011)
What the evidence can't tell us
- The city council study covers only four Southwestern cities, which its author says are not a representative sample of U.S. cities. (Trounstine, 2011)
- The mayor study's main estimates measure the chance of running and winning again rather than share of the vote, because vote share would mix in whether candidates choose to run again, a choice unlikely to be random. (de Benedictis-Kessner, 2018)
- The count of presidents running again includes vice presidents who took over the job, such as Harry Truman and Gerald Ford, and leaves out the elections of 1788 and 1824. (Mayhew, 2013)
Sources
Every study here was read in a free copy, linked below. A number on this page comes only from a study read in full; one read only in its summary is described in words.
- Gary C. Jacobson (2025). The 2024 Presidential and Congressional Elections: Small Wave, Seismic Effects. Political Science Quarterly 140(3), open access (CC BY). Free copy · Publisher's page
- Gary C. Jacobson (2015). It's Nothing Personal: The Decline of the Incumbency Advantage in US House Elections. Journal of Politics 77(3). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)
- Stephen Ansolabehere and James M. Snyder, Jr. (2012). The Effects of Redistricting on Incumbents. Election Law Journal 11(4); read as the authors' August 2012 version in Harvard's DASH open-access repository. Free copy · Publisher's page
- Joel Sievert and Seth C. McKee (2019). Nationalization in U.S. Senate and Gubernatorial Elections. American Politics Research 47(5). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)
- David R. Mayhew (2013). The Meaning of the 2012 Election. Pre-edit version of Chapter 9 in Michael Nelson (ed.), The Elections of 2012 (CQ Press, 2013), posted by Yale's Institution for Social and Policy Studies; its Table 1 updates Table 2 of Mayhew's 2008 Political Science Quarterly article. Free copy
- Justin de Benedictis-Kessner (2018). Off-Cycle and Out of Office: Election Timing and the Incumbency Advantage. Journal of Politics 80(1); read as the author's posted preprint of August 23, 2017 (linked from his Harvard page). Free copy · Publisher's page
- Jessica Trounstine (2011). Evidence of a Local Incumbency Advantage. Legislative Studies Quarterly 36(2); read as the published version posted on the author's university site. Free copy · Publisher's page