Do debates change votes?
The short answer
- Debates rarely change how people vote: a study of 56 TV debates in seven countries finds no detectable effect on how voters reach their final choice. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- Debates can still teach: a review of many studies of U.S. presidential debates finds that watching a general election debate raises what viewers know about the issues. (Benoit, Hansen and Verser, 2003)
- Where voters have little other political information, debates can move votes, as an experiment in Sierra Leone's 2012 parliamentary elections shows. (Bidwell, Casey and Glennerster, 2020)
What the studies found
- In 62 elections in ten countries from 1952 to 2017, between 17% and 29% of voters made up their minds in the last two months of the campaign. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- On average, the same study rules out a debate raising, in the three days after it, the share of voters whose stated choice before the election matches their final vote by more than 0.5 percentage point. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- It finds no sign that debates help any group of voters settle on their final choice, including people who watched, and none for a campaign's first debate or for debates in close races. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- That study also finds no detectable debate effect on whether voters' views of the candidates before the election match their views after it. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- A review of U.S. presidential debate studies finds that debates can affect which candidate viewers prefer, and that the first debate in a series has a larger effect than later ones. (Benoit, Hansen and Verser, 2003)
- In the 2000 U.S. presidential race, one study finds that support for George W. Bush rose after the debates, while support for Al Gore did not. (Hillygus and Jackman, 2003)
- In the 2012 U.S. presidential race, polls swung toward Mitt Romney after the first debate, but in one study's panel of Xbox users asked again and again, only 0.5% switched from Barack Obama to Romney. (Gelman, Goel, Rivers and Rothschild, 2016)
- In Sierra Leone's 2012 parliamentary elections, public screenings of debate videos raised the vote share of candidates whom experts judged the best debaters by 3.5 percentage points on average. (Bidwell, Casey and Glennerster, 2020)
- During the second TV debate of Germany's 2002 national election, audience members of differing political leanings all approved of widely accepted statements and self-praise, while attacks, factual evidence and detailed plans tended to split the two candidates' supporters. (Reinemann and Maurer, 2005)
- In three U.S. lab experiments, a TV exchange of opposing views did not by itself harm attitudes toward politics, but the same exchange done rudely lowered viewers' trust. (Mutz and Reeves, 2005)
- Fewer races hold debates: an ABC News count in September 2026 found no major-party debate set in 21 of 36 governor races and 21 of 35 Senate races. (ABC News, 2026)
- A review of many studies of U.S. presidential debates finds that watching a general election debate raises what viewers know about the issues and how many issues they use to judge the candidates. (Benoit, Hansen and Verser, 2003)
What the evidence can't tell us
- Studies disagree: many earlier studies comparing opinion before and after a debate find small or no effects, while others find that debates matter, and the 62-election study argues this method cannot separate a debate from the campaign's general drift. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- The 56 debates in the 62-election study were all for president or prime minister, so its finding is about the top national race, not races for governor, mayor or Congress. (Le Pennec and Pons, 2023)
- The rudeness experiments used a staged TV talk show with actors playing two congressional candidates, not a real campaign debate. (Mutz and Reeves, 2005)
Sources
Every study here was read in a free copy, linked below. A number on this page comes only from a study read in full; one read only in its summary is described in words.
- Caroline Le Pennec and Vincent Pons (2023). How Do Campaigns Shape Vote Choice? Multicountry Evidence from 62 Elections and 56 TV Debates. Quarterly Journal of Economics 138(2); read as NBER Working Paper 26572, revised December 2022. Free copy · Publisher's page
- William L. Benoit, Glenn J. Hansen and Rebecca M. Verser (2003). A meta-analysis of the effects of viewing U.S. presidential debates. Communication Monographs 70(4). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)
- Andrew Gelman, Sharad Goel, Douglas Rivers and David Rothschild (2016). The Mythical Swing Voter. Quarterly Journal of Political Science 11. Free copy · Publisher's page
- D. Sunshine Hillygus and Simon Jackman (2003). Voter Decision Making in Election 2000: Campaign Effects, Partisan Activation, and the Clinton Legacy. American Journal of Political Science 47(4). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)
- Kelly Bidwell, Katherine Casey and Rachel Glennerster (2020). Debates: Voting and Expenditure Responses to Political Communication. Journal of Political Economy 128(8); read as Stanford King Center Working Paper 1045, revision of 15 March 2019. Free copy · Publisher's page
- Carsten Reinemann and Marcus Maurer (2005). Unifying or Polarizing? Short-Term Effects and Postdebate Consequences of Different Rhetorical Strategies in Televised Debates. Journal of Communication 55(4). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)
- Diana C. Mutz and Byron Reeves (2005). The New Videomalaise: Effects of Televised Incivility on Political Trust. American Political Science Review 99(1). Free copy · Publisher's page
- Diana Paulsen (2026). Midterm candidates dumping debates: 'There's no reason to get up there and argue about differences of opinion'. ABC News, September 25, 2026 (news count, cited only for a plain event). Free copy