Do attack ads work, and should a candidate answer them?
The short answer
- A 2007 review of research finds no good evidence that negative campaigning is an effective way to win votes, even though attacks tend to be more memorable. (Lau, Sigelman and Rovner, 2007)
- Attacks can backfire: in an Italian experiment with a made-up race for mayor, the attacker lost support while the target did not. (Galasso, Nannicini and Nunnari, 2023)
- In a U.S. experiment with a made-up House race, an attack hurt the incumbent (the person already in office), and answering it, for example with a denial, won support back. (Craig and Rippere, 2016)
What the studies found
- That review finds no reliable evidence that negative campaigning lowers turnout, though it slightly lowers people's sense that they can affect government and their trust in it. (Lau, Sigelman and Rovner, 2007)
- An earlier U.S. study disagrees: in its experiments, watching negative ads lowered people's stated plans to vote, and it reports a matching pattern in the 1992 Senate elections. (Ansolabehere, Iyengar, Simon and Valentino, 1994)
- In a 2012 online experiment with 662 U.S. registered voters and a made-up House race, a challenger's attack cut the incumbent's support by 18.1 points, from 50.3% to 32.2%. (Craig and Rippere, 2016)
- The attacker's own favorability rating also fell, by 0.512 points on a 7-point scale, but the authors judge that going negative still gave a sizable net advantage. (Craig and Rippere, 2016)
- In that experiment, a denial after the attack won back 23.1 percentage points of vote share for male incumbents; the authors find no statistically significant difference between male and female incumbents in how well responses worked. (Craig and Rippere, 2016)
- In a 2015 race for mayor in Cava de' Tirreni, Italy, a third candidate's vote share was 3.7 percentage points higher where one challenger's volunteers canvassed with negative messages about the incumbent than where they used positive ones. (Galasso, Nannicini and Nunnari, 2023)
- In that real election, the negative messages had no statistically clear effect on the incumbent or on the attacker, though both estimates were negative. (Galasso, Nannicini and Nunnari, 2023)
- In the same study's online experiment with 2,971 Italian volunteers and a made-up two-candidate race, the challenger's support fell from 54% to 46% after a calm attack, and to 32.5% after an aggressive one. (Galasso, Nannicini and Nunnari, 2023)
- A 2007 review of research on negative campaigning finds no good evidence that it is an effective way to win votes, though attacks tend to be more memorable and teach people about the campaign. (Lau, Sigelman and Rovner, 2007)
What the evidence can't tell us
- The attack-and-response findings come from one online experiment with a made-up House race and a single attack on the incumbent's job performance, so real campaigns may differ. (Craig and Rippere, 2016)
- The authors warn that some groups in their experiment were small, so real differences between groups may have gone undetected. (Craig and Rippere, 2016)
- The Italian field experiment covered one town, and its authors say its null results for the attacker and target may come from its small sample. (Galasso, Nannicini and Nunnari, 2023)
Sources
Every study here was read in a free copy, linked below. A number on this page comes only from a study read in full; one read only in its summary is described in words.
- Richard R. Lau, Lee Sigelman and Ivy Brown Rovner (2007). The Effects of Negative Political Campaigns: A Meta-Analytic Reassessment. Journal of Politics 69(4). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)
- Vincenzo Galasso, Tommaso Nannicini and Salvatore Nunnari (2023). Positive Spillovers from Negative Campaigning. American Journal of Political Science 67(1). Free copy · Publisher's page
- Stephen C. Craig and Paulina S. Rippere (2016). He Said, She Said: The Impact of Candidate Gender in Negative Campaigns. Politics and Gender 12(2). Free copy · Publisher's page
- Stephen Ansolabehere, Shanto Iyengar, Adam Simon and Nicholas Valentino (1994). Does Attack Advertising Demobilize the Electorate?. American Political Science Review 88(4). Free copy · Publisher's page (summary only: no figures taken from it)